Hamidah Hamidah


The IFRS can be applied in the multi national company (MNC) and listing firms across the countrybut it does not mean it can replace the national accounting standards that have been owned by respectivecountries. The accounting standardization is not an easy job because each country has differentpolitical, social, and economic background. This study is to reveal the reason and who is behindIFRS adoption in Indonesia. This qualitative research is a case study based on cases representinginstitutions in Indonesia: DSAK, DPN IAI, BAPEPAM-LK, the finance ministry and the ministryof state own enterprises (BUMN). Data were collected by interviews and using readily availabledocuments and processed with thematic analysis. The result shows the adoption of IFRS decisions isdriven by international interests. Indonesia's membership in several international organizations, suchas IFAC (International Federation on Accountant), IOSCO, and the G-20, has resulted in the approvalof global accounting standards in Indonesia. Each organization has done a variety ways toensure that its members adopt IFRS. IFRS should be based more on Indonesia accounting needs andshould not be only based on a desire particularly coercion from others. In-depth analysis based onthe reality of each particular business should be conducted before a decision to adopt IFRS is taken.


Adoption;IFRS;Case Studies;International Interest;Coercion

Full Text:



Abeysekera, I 2005, International Harmonization

of Accounting Imperialism an

Australian Perspectives, Paper Presented

at the Critical Management


Albu, N, Albu, CN, Bunea, S, Calu, DA, &

Girbina, MM 2010, A Story about

IAS/IFRS Implementation in Romania

An Institutional and Structuration

Theory Perspectives, 31st Congress of

the Association Francophone De

Comptabilit, Nice, France.

Alp, A & Ustundag, S 2009, Financial Reporting

Transformation: The Experience

Of Turkey, Critical Perspectives

on Accounting, 20, 680.

Alsharairi, MA 2005, The Impact Of

Adopting International Accounting

Standards on The Jordanian Environment:

The Perspective Of Accountants,

Auditors and Academicians - An

Exploratory Study [Electronic Version],

Retrieved 1 December 2012,


Belkaoui, 2004, Accounting Theory, London,


Boolaky, PK 2004, Determinants of Accounting

Standards in The Southern

African Development Community

(SADC), Journal of Accounting Research,


Briston, RJ 1978, The Evolution of Accounting

in Developing Countries, International

Journal of Accounting, 14


Briston, RJ 1990, Accounting in Developing

Countries: Indonesia and the

Solomon Island As Case Studies For

Regional Cooperation, Research In

Third World Accounting, 1, 195-216.

Bruce, J 2009, IFRS on The G-20 Docket?,

_and_g-20>, Retrieved 5 December

Chamisa, EE 2000, The Relevance And

Observance Of The IASC Standards in

Developing Countries and The Particular

Case of Zimbabwe, The International

Journal Of Accounting, 35,


Chand, P & White, M 2007, A Critique of

the Influence of Globalization and

Convergence of Accounting Standards

In Fiji, Critical Perspectives on Accounting,

, 605-622.

Choi, F & Mueller, G 1984, International

Accounting, New Jersey, Prentice Hall.

Creswell, JW, Hanson, WE, Clark, VLP &

Morales, A 2007, Qualitative Research

Designs: Selection And Implementation,

The Counseling Psychologist,

, 236-264.

G-20, 2009, Leaders' Statement the Pittsburgh

Summit September 24-25 2009,


sep-2009>, Retrieved 6 December

Hopwood, AG 1978, Towards an Organizational

Perspective for the Study of Accounting

and Information Systems,

Accounting, Organizations and Society,

Accounting, Organization and

Society, 3, 3-13.

IFAC, 2006, Statements of Membership Obligation,

Retrieved 5 December 2012,



IFAC, 2009, Recommendations for The G20

Nations, Retrieved 5 December 2013,



IFAC, 2011a, History, Retrieved 8 December



IFAC, 2011b, Members Bodies, Retrieved 8

December 2013,


IFAC, 2011c, Membership, Retrieved 8 December



IFAC, 2011d, Organization Overview, Retrieved

December 2013,


IFRS Foundation, 2012, MoU between IASB

and IFAC, Retrieved 18 December




IOSCO, 2005, Development and Use of International

Financial Reporting Standards

in 2005, Retrieved 21 December



Koenig-Archibugi, M 2003, Mapping Global

Governance [Electronic Version], The

Governance of Global Issues: Effectiveness,

Accountability, and Constitutionalization,

Retrieved 25 December

, .

Mattli, W & Buthe, T 2006, Global Private

Governance: Lesson from A National

Model of Setting Standards In Accounting,

Law And Contemporary

Problems, 68.

Miles, MB & Huberman, AM 1994, Qualitative

Data Analysis, Thousand Oaks,

Sage Publications.

Nobes, CW 1998, Towards a General

Model of the Reasons for International

Differences in Financial Reporting,

Abacus, 34, 162-187.

Perry, J & Andreas, N 2006, The political

economy of international accounting

standards, Review of International

Political Economy, 13, 559-586.

Ritchie, J & Lewis, J (Eds), 2003, Qualitative

Research Practice a Guide for Social

Science Students and Researchers,

London Sage Publications.

Sinaga, RU & Wahyuni, ET 2012, Out of

Shadows, Acca Magazine, Juli 2012


Soderstrom, NS, & Sun, KJ 2010, IFRS

Adoption and Accounting Quality: A

Review [Electronic Version], Retrieved

Augusts 2010,


Sugiono, 2010, Memahami Penelitian Kualitatif,

Bandung, Alfabeta.

Tyrrall, D, Woodman, D & Rakhimbekova,

A 2007, The Relevance of International

Financial Reporting Standards

to a Developing Country: Evidence

from Kazakhstan, The International

Journal of Accounting, 42, 82-110.

Wulandari, ER 2011, The Opportunities

and Challenges of IFRS Convergence:

Views of Market Regulators, 5th IFRS

Regional Policy Forum & International

Seminar, Bali, IAI Global.

Yin, RK 2003, Case Study Research: Design

and Method, Thousand Oaks, Ca, Sage

Publication Incorporated.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c)

Abstracting & Indexing


Hasil gambar untuk ccbyncsa

Copyright @ 2010 Pusat Penelitian dan Pengabdian Masyarakat Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi (PPPM STIE)