Zaenal Abidin, Emilyn Cabanda


It is a fact that financial institutions among Asian countries, especially Indonesia, have been
dominated by commercial banks. In addition, an insurance market share is only 10 percent of
the financial market. Yet, the insurance industry is an important partner for the banking industry.
This function is to guarantee the risk of banks in distributing credit and supporting
the national economy through the community's fund. This paper evaluates the relative efficiency
of 23 Non Life Insurance companies in Indonesia, using Data Envelopment Analysis
(DEA) model. DEA is a management evaluation tool that assists in identifying the most efficient
and inefficient decision-making units (DMUs) in the best practice frontier. Empirical
results show that bigger insurance companies are found to be more efficient than smaller
firms. Moreover, companies with captive market and the company's group with non-captive
market have relatively the same result. These findings are new empirical contributions to
efficiency literature of the insurance industry. The paper also provides policy implications
for the Indonesian insurance sector.


Non Life Insurance;Data Envelopment Analysis;Technical Efficiency

Full Text:

Full Article (pdf)


Abidin and Cabanda, 2006, Financial and

Production Performances of Domestic

and Foreign Banks in Indonesia: Pre

and Post Financial Crisis. Manajemen

Usahawan Indonesia, No.06, 3 - 9

Banker, R. D., Charnes, A., Cooper, W.W

, Some models for estimating

technical and scale inefficiencies in

data envelopment analysis. Management

Science 30,1078-1092.

Barr, Richard, K. Killgo, F. Siems and S.

Table 2

Linkage between Profitability Ratios and DEA Performance

Variables Dependent : DEA Coefficient P- value


C 0.5135 0.0000

ROA -0.0076 0.2506

ROE 0.0060 0.3051

NPM 0.0008(*) 0.0776

( ) Indicates p-value. *, ** significant at 0.10, 0.05 probability level, respectively.

Zimmel, 2002, Evaluating the Productive

Efficiency and Performance of

U.S. Commercial Banks. Managerial

Finance vol.28 no.8.

Berger, N. Allen and D.B Humphrey, 1992,

Measurement and Efficiency issue in

Commercial Banking. National bureau

of Economic Research, University of

Chicago Press.

Bos, Jaap W. and Kolari, James, 2005, Large

Bank Efficiency in Europe and the

United States: Are There Economics

Motivations for Geographic Expansion

in Financial Service? The Journal of

Business; July;78,4 pg 1555.

Brockett, L Patrick, William W. Cooper,

Linda L.Golden, John J. Rousseau, and

Yuying Wang, 2005, Financial intermediary

versus production approach to

efficiency of marketing distribution

system and organizational structure of

insurance companies. The journal of

risk and insurance, Vol 72. No. 3.


Coelli, Tim, 1996, A Guide to Frontier version

1: A computer program for Stochastic

Frontier Production and Cost

Function Estimation. Australia : CEPA

Working Paper.

Coelli, Tim, Rao, D.S and G. Battese, 1998,

An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity

Analysis. United States of

America; Kluwer Academic Publisher.

Coelli, Tim and Rao, Prasada, 2003, Total

Factor Productivity in Agriculture: A

malmquist Index Analysis of 93 Countries,

2000. University of

Queensland, Australia. CEPA, Working

paper series No.02/2003.

Denizer, A. Cevdet and Dinc Mustafa, 2000,

Measuring Banking Efficiency in the

pre and Post Liberalization Environment:

Evidence from the Turkish

Banking System. George Washington


Eling Martin and Michael Luhnen, 2008,

Frontier efficiency methodologies to

measure performance in the insurance

industry: overview and new empirical

evidence. Working papers on risk

management and insurance no 56.

University of St. Gallen.

Huang Li Ying, Tzy-yih Hsiao, and Gene c.

Lai, 2007, Does Corporate and Ownweship

Structure Influence Performance?

Evidence from Taiwan Life Insurance

Companies. Journal of Insurance

Issues. 30, 2, 123 151.

Hwang Shiuh-Nan and Tong-Liang Kao,

, Measuring Managerial Efficiency

in Non Life Insurance Companies

: An Aplication of Two Stage

Data Envelopment Analysis. International

Journal of Management Vol 23

No.3, 699 720.

Karim, Mohd Zaini Abd, 2001, Comparative

Bank Efficiency Across Select

ASEAN Countries. ASEAN Economic

Bulletin vol.18: 289.

Li, Shanling, S. Liu and G.A Whitmore,

, Comparative Performance of

Chinese Commercial Banks. China:

Review of Quantitative Finance and

Accounting, January.

Mahadevan, Renuka, 2003, To Measure or

Not To Measure Total Factor Productivity

Growth?. Oxford Development

Studies, vol.31, no.3.365 378.

Oral, M and R.Yolalan, 1990, An Emperical

Study on Measurement Operating

Efficiency and Profitability of Bank

Branches. European Journal of Operational

Research, 46, 282-94.

Vencappa Dev, Paul Fenn, and Stephen Diacon,

, Parametric Decomposition

of Total Factor Productivity Growth in

the European Insurance Industry: Evidence

from Life and Non-Life Companies.

Working Paper. Nottingham

University Business School. United


DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.14414/jebav.v14i3.46


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c)

Abstracting & Indexing



Hasil gambar untuk ccbyncsa

Copyright @ 2010 Pusat Penelitian dan Pengabdian Masyarakat Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi (PPPM STIE)